- Author: Steven A. Tjosvold
The previous blog post explained how moving air helps maximize photosynthesis by increasing the ambient CO2 diffusion into the leaf. The trick is to efficiently move air around the greenhouse so that can happen.
Since 1967, when the Horizontal Air Flow (HAF) concept was introduced by Dr. Jay Koths, from the University of Connecticut , it has become the standard method for air circulation in greenhouses. Over the years, changes to fan design, installation techniques and efficiency have brought some improvements to the original design. But the HAF concepts and benefits have not changed at all. I scanned one of the original newsletter articles that Dr Koths wrote in 1985 (available below). It explains the concepts and practical design features as well as anyone ever could.
- Author: Steven A. Tjosvold
We measured greenhouse carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations within the leaf canopy of roses grown for cut flowers over several years. Often, during the day we found the CO2 concentration was depleted to levels as low as 225 ppm, even though vents were opened. Apparently, CO2 was being absorbed quickly by the rose leaves and fresh air was not moving sufficiently into the plant leaf canopy to replenish the CO2 to normal atmospheric levels (340 ppm in 1985). This was also noted in a greenhouse cucumber experiment in Spain in 2005 , where CO2 was found to be from 50 to 60 ppm lower than the atmospheric concentration during the day, again even though vents were open. (Then atmospheric CO2 was measured at about 360 ppm). (See Sanchez, 2005 below ) .
Generally, a drop of CO2 level below the normal atmospheric concentration has a stronger relative effect on photosynthesis than enrichment above the normal atmospheric concentration. Illustrated above in this 1985 figure when the atmospheric CO2 concentration was 340 ppm.
In the previous blog, I wrote about the potential benefit and difficulty of greenhouse CO2 enrichment above normal atmospheric CO2 levels. I showed that the opportunity for enrichment in climates that have high greenhouse ventilation requirements is limited. So how do you make the best use of the existing CO2 (that is, with no enrichment)?
The goal is to get fresh outside air into the greenhouse, then around the crop, then around the leaves that are providing most of the photosynthetic capacity of the plant (which is usually the mature upper leaves of the plant). This is done more or less in field crops with natural air movement. But within the greenhouse confines, this is done by ventilation to exchange greenhouse and outside air, and circulate the greenhouse air with fans.
What are the effects of moving air on the leaf micro-environment, CO2, and photosynthesis?
The benefits of moving air on photosynthesis has been widely studied. Here's one example showing the results from an experiment on tomato in growth chambers. This shows the effect of CO2 and air velocity on net photosynthesis (Pn) See Thongbai 2010 below
LL= low CO2 (200-300 ppm) + Low air velocity (0.3 m/s)
LH= low CO2 (200-300 ppm) + High air velocity (1.0 m/s)
HL= high CO2 (500 - 600 ppm) + Low air velocity (0.3 m/s)
HH= high CO2 (500 - 600 ppm) + high air velocity (1.0 m/s)
Photosynthesis in both levels of CO2 (low and high) were enhanced with the Low to High velocity of air movement. The Low velocity is about in the low range of the recommended velocity of air flow with a greenhouse horizontal air flow circulation system (about 0.25 m/s = 50 ft/min).
So why the enhancement of photosynthesis?
Earlier research showed that insufficient air movement around plants generally limits photosynthesis by suppressing the gas diffusion in the leaf boundary-layer. This is the conceptual layer of still air that surrounds the leaf. With increasing wind velocity the boundary layer becomes thinner and resistance decreases (top graph). More gas diffusion can take place through the leaf pores (stomata). With more CO2 diffusion into the leaf, photosynthesis increases (middle graph). Consequently, transpiration (loss of water from the leaf through stomata) also increases (bottom graph). Excessive wind velocity and water stress will causes the leaf pores to close (not shown). So there has got to be the correct balance. Not too much air movement, not too little, and the plants have to be irrigated properly in the first place. (See Kitaya, 2003 below)
The optimum air circulation for photosynthesis depends on the plant species, structure and depth of the plant canopy, among other factors. In general, plant air circulation has been provided by venting of greenhouses and air circulation with various fan systems.
In the next post, I'll bring to light one of the classic systems, HAF, horizontal air flow system.