- Author: Umair Gull
- Author: Rachael Long
- Author: Isaya Kisekka
- Author: Khaled Bali
Looking a little dry out there?
January and February of 2021 were some of the driest months on record, with near Zero (1.7”) precipitation in Northern California. Things don't look good for summer. What can alfalfa growers do under these conditions?
Drought Coming. Currently much of the Southwest US is under ‘extreme' to ‘exceptional drought', depending upon the region (Figure 1). A key issue for many regions is snow pack – which currently is at about 60% of normal. Although we've had some recent precipitation, the trend is for relatively low rainfall for the rest of the month of March. Allocations of surface water to the large irrigation districts are scheduled to be a fraction of normal in 2021.
Figure 1. Drought Conditions in SW US (USDA, NOAA, Nat'l Drought monitoring Center, Lincoln, NB. March 16, 2021.
Alfalfa is a great crop that typically survives droughts successfully (see blog ‘Why Alfalfa is the best crop to Have in a Drought'). But is it a good idea to just ‘let it go'?? What is the strategy for producing alfalfa during droughts? We recommend starting early, with the possibility that you'll have to stop watering later in the season!
We've conducted several studies that may help shed light on this question.
Figure 2. Weather Patterns from October, 2020 to March, 2021, Davis, CA. ETo (plant water demand) was about 302 mm (12 inches) of water, while winter rainfall totaled only 122 mm (4.8 inches) by mid-March.
RE-WATERING STUDIES (UC Davis)
In 2019-2020, we conducted an irrigation study at UC Davis utilizing overhead irrigation system with Low Elevation Spray Application (LESA) sprinklers and Mobile Drip Irrigation (MDI) or dragging drip lines (Gull et al., in prep). Both systems performed well. In those two years, we imposed a series of droughts or ‘deficit irrigation' treatments which created many areas of the field that were lower yielding due to the water deficits. Normally, at Davis we will receive sufficient rainfall to fill the profile each year– but as of early March, 2021, very little effective rainfall occurred. This allowed us the opportunity to impose an irrigation trial that would test the value of very early spring (e.g. late winter) irrigation and its effect on growth and yield on previously fully irrigated or deficit irrigated plots.
Crop Regrowth. In early 2021, we divided the field up in replicated plots and irrigated ½ the study with flood irrigation applications of about 12” of water in February. Perhaps not surprisingly, the plants responded very quickly. The warm sunny conditions in February/March resulted in much superior growth in those plots compared with non-irrigated plots (Figure 3). The Normalized Difference Red Edge (NDRE) index, an estimate of plant growth and vigor, was better in the irrigated plots vs. non-irrigated plots (Figure 4).
Figure 3. Effect of winter irrigation on alfalfa regrowth. Plots with winter irrigation applied February 22, 2021 (left side) exhibited much more vigorous early growth than non-irrigated plots (right).
Figure 4. Normalized Difference Red Edge Index (NDRE) indicates the plant vigor (growth) in February-irrigated (blue) and non-irrigated (red) plots.
Soil Moisture Changes. Difference in water status between winter irrigated plots and no-winter irrigated plots in the Davis trial showed very dry conditions in early February (Figures 5 and 6). In plots that were relatively well-watered in 2020 (Figure 5), a single irrigation was sufficient to bring many parts of the subsoil back to a full profile (Figure 5A), while plots with no winter irrigation continued to dry down (Figure 5B). In plots that were stressed in 2020, it was more difficult to fill the profile, and lack of winter irrigation had a severe effect on soil moisture (Figure 6).
Figure 5. In plots that received 100% of their ET in 2020, a single irrigation in early February resulted in filling the profile (5A). However, without winter irrigation (5B), the sub-soil continued to dry down. Winter rains only impacted the top 12” of the soil profile. (Davis, CA).
Figure 6. A February watering partially filled the top part of the profile (6C) of previously stressed plots, but not as successfully as Figure 5A. Without winter irrigation, the subsoil continued to remain very dry through late February (6D) in previously stressed plots. (Davis, CA).
RE-WATERING/WINTER FLOODING STUDIES (Fresno County)
At the University of California Research and Extension Center (Parlier, CA), in Fresno County, an experiment was conducted to examine the effects of winter flood irrigation on growth and yield of alfalfa. While this was designed for winter recharge of aquifers, it gave us an opportunity to understand the effects of winter watering on alfalfa growth. In this case, we also had late-summer deficit irrigation treatments in the previous year. In 2019-20, we found that winter irrigation increase yield during that production year, particularly in the first three harvest periods, both in plots that were deficit irrigated and those that had received full irrigation the previous year (Figure 7).
Figure 7. Effect of winter flood irrigation on 2020 alfalfa yields that were either fully irrigated or deficit irrigated in 2019. UC Kearney Research and Extension Center, Parlier, CA.
In many parts of California and other Western States, winter rains are almost always insufficient to allow vigorous regrowth in the spring. In Buttonwillow (near Bakersfield), average rainfall is about 7”/year, almost all between November and March. Therefore, many growers understand the value of these winter water applications. On a drip irrigated field in Buttonwillow, CA, the growers have flood irrigated this field in February of 2020, even though it will be drip -irrigated for most of the year. They do this because 1) it fills the soil profile early, and 2) flood irrigation assists in controlling gopher populations
Figure 8. Flood irrigation in February, 2020 on an (otherwise) drip irrigated field in Buttonwillow, CA. This grower flood irrigates 2x per year, but uses drip irrigation for most of the year.
In our view, in a dry spring period, fill that profile early!! We believe that it is not only beneficial to the first growth period, but also likely to be helpful in mid-summer as well. The highest yielding and highest quality production is in the first several cuttings of the year. Late cuttings of alfalfa are typically 50-60-% the yields of those first cuttings. Therefore, in a drought year, it's important to water early, to fill the profile, maximize production during the early period. Probe your soil! Any way to estimate profiles soil moisture would be help even with simple time-tested technologies like steel soil probe and 'look and feel' for soil moisture. If one has to stop irrigating in mid-summer due to lack of water, the early growth will make up for the lack of production later. Once you're behind, it's hard to catch up.
We appreciate the contributions of Maya Hotz, Jonathan Misael Cisneros, Michelle M Leinfelder-Miles, Chris DeBen for their help in the project. Many thanks to Travis Parker for allowing us to use the UAV and helping in imagery acquisition. Many thanks to the National Alfalfa and Forage Alliance (NAFA), and to the USDA-NIFA-AFRI Alfalfa Program for providing support for conducting the project, and to Senninger Inc. and Valley Irrigation.