- Author: Judy Quan
Spring is here, and it is time to think about fertilizing citrus and fruit trees, berries, flowering ornamentals, and vegetables. Decisions need to be made about whether to fertilize, what to fertilize, how much to fertilize. The first article “Home Gardening Fertilizing Part 1: Fertilizers 101” in this series on Fertilizers and Fertilizing talked about what fertilizers are, what they are composed of and what different forms they come in.
This article, “Home Gardening Fertilizing Part 2: Spring is Here. Is It Time to Fertilize?”, the second of the three-part series on Fertilizers, is divided into two sections: (1) Analyze and Test; (2) Learn About and Then Select the Fertilizer Type(s) You Want to Use.
The question of fertilizing, how much and when is a complicated question. The decision of whether to fertilize should be based upon the health of the plant and the type of soil as well as what is happening growth-wise and with fruit and flower production. If you are satisfied with the growth, appearance, and health of your plants, you may not need to fertilize. Most of your landscape trees and shrubs do not need fertilizing to grow well. California natives do not need to be fertilized because they are adapted to California soils.
First Steps: Analyze and test
Take a look around your garden analyzing your plants, their appearance and size, and whether they produced what you hoped for.
Yellowing leaves has many causes and does not automatically mean that fertilizer is needed.
For instance, plants often show yellowing leaves in early spring when soils are too wet and/or too cold for their roots to absorb nutrients. In that case, applying nitrogen fertilizer will not fix the yellowing of the leaves.
Nitrogen deficiency symptoms include slow growth, yellowing leaves in older leaves, smaller than normal fruit, leaves and shoots.
Nitrogen deficiency may not be just because of a deficit in nitrogen in the soil. Nitrogen deficiency symptoms such as slow growth and yellowing leaves may be due to poor soil conditions, unhealthy roots or even cool soil temperatures.
Fruit trees, especially citrus, usually need fertilizing as do vegetable gardens and some flowering ornamentals.
Why should you care about overfertilization? It is important to know whether fertilization is needed or not and how much since too much fertilizer can cause problems for plants and the environment.
Overfertilization can lead to excessive growth which in turn leads to more pruning, increased need for water, and more pests. If you are unsure, using less is best.
Too much nitrogen can promote leafy green at the cost of reduced fruit production. Too much nitrogen and phosphorus can lead to “dead zones” causing fish kills and a decrease in aquatic life.
To avoid overfertilization, test your soil for nutrients and pH.
Testing for nutrients
To determine the amount of fertilization, first do some home testing of the soil for the three components of fertilizer: nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K).
California soils are typically low on nitrogen whereas potassium is usually adequate. Although Alameda County has areas with sandy soil along the bay, especially in the island city of Alameda; much of Alameda County soil is clay. Clay soil typically holds more nutrients than sandy soil.
Test the soil for nutrients in spring and fall and adjust the amount/type of fertilizer to achieve an acceptable level.
Testing for pH
You might also consider a pH test since pH can affect whether nutrients are available to plants. Typically, most plants do best when the pH is slightly acidic to neutral (pH of 5.5 to 7.5). What is pH and why do we care? This article will tell you: https://anrcatalog.ucanr.edu/pdf/8488.pdf. If plants show deficiency symptoms, make sure that the pH is appropriate for the plants that you are cultivating. If the pH is right but you still have symptoms, then consideration of fertilizers based on soil tests is appropriate. Here is an excellent article by Jim Downer, UC farmer advisor, "My Soil is Crap, Part II" that explains what impacts soil health and practical information on improving soil health.
Home Soil Test Kits
Many retail gardening centers offer commercial soil test kits for testing for nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and pH. When considering the accuracy of the tests, these kits can provide sufficient information with convenience and low cost, according to UC farm advisors Dr Ben Faber and Jim Downer.
There are pH test strips that are also available at your local nursery, which can give you a general idea of the pH in your soil. Here is an article that defines pH, pH testing and how to adjust soil pH. Be patient when trying to adjust pH, adding any amendments affecting pH in small amounts and testing pH again.
Second Steps: Learn about and select the right fertilizer types
Once you have soil test results, then comes the process of selecting the product that best fits your needs. There are so many choices and so many confusing terms. Fertilizer, soil amendment, what is the difference between them? Organic or inorganic fertilizers, what is the difference and how to best use them?
Fertilizers and soil amendments affect plant growth differently, and the definition is blurred when organic fertilizers are considered because they fall into both the fertilizer and the soil amendment categories.
Fertilizer or Soil Amendment? Or Both? The effect of a material on plant growth determines whether it is considered a fertilizer or soil amendment. Fertilizers affect plant growth directly by improving the supply of available nutrients in the soil. Soil amendments influence plant growth indirectly by improving the soil's physical properties or chemical properties. However, the difference between fertilizers and soil amendments is not so clear when evaluating natural or organic products.
Organics may also improve physical properties of soil, such as improving its structure and water-holding or drainage capacity. If they do, they are also considered to be soil amendments.
Fertilizer may be organic or inorganic, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Plants respond equally well to organic or inorganic (chemical) forms of fertilizers. The general belief that organic materials are better sources of plant nutrients than inorganic forms is not correct. Often, organics might be chosen as a fertilizer for other reasons. For example, some organic fertilizers such as compost can also help with improving the physical characteristics of soils by increasing water drainage for clay soils or increasing water holding capacity for sandy soils.
Organic versus Inorganic Fertilizer as Source of Nutrients
Pros and Cons of Organic and Inorganic fertilizers
Organic fertilizers are usually derived from various manures or concentrated organic materials like blood meal, fish meal, and bone meal. Organics usually cost more than synthetics and vary widely in nutrient content. Organics generally are more slowly released than inorganic fertilizers. Fresh manures must be aged before use to allow time for decomposition and leaching of excess salts. Otherwise, the plants may be damaged. Manures may also contain weed seeds. Purchased manure products are pre-aged and ready to use. Since organics are slower to release, there is less likelihood of excess runoff and leaching of fertilizer.
Inorganic (synthetic, chemical) fertilizers are composed of mined minerals or man-made chemical compounds that provide combinations of plant-essential nutrients. Common examples are urea, ammonium nitrate, ammonium sulfate, superphosphate and muriate of potash (potassium chloride). Inorganic fertilizers are typically fast-acting and cheaper. Some inorganic fertilizers, like ammonium sulfate, can acidify the soil and others, like urea or calcium nitrate, will tend to raise the pH. Important disadvantages to inorganics are the potential to contaminate the environment due to leaching or run-off, and to burn plants if not applied according to the package directions.
Many gardeners will use a combination of the two types. Chemical fertilizers can be more reliably measured whereas organic fertilizers may vary more but organic fertilizers may have the added benefit of improving the physical or chemical properties of soil too.
Once you have an idea of what you want to use, consider why you want to fertilize and what that means for the N-P-K ratio of the product. Home Gardening Fertilizing, Part 1: Fertilizing 101 reviews what N-P-K does and how to read the fertilizer label.
Here are some general practical tips on fertilizing:
- Remember that plants often have different fertilizer needs. For instance, some plants don't need fertilizer. Some need only a little, like young starter plants that are sensitive to over fertilizing.
- Read the label for the N-P-K levels.
- Following the application directions carefully. If the fertilizer comes with a measuring spoon, save the spoon and use per label instructions. Don't guess the quantity needed.
- Water the plants thoroughly before and after application to minimize plant burn.
- If applying dry fertilizer, scratch it into soil so it is mixed lightly into soil.
- Wait until the weather is dry to fertilize, so fertilizer doesn't wash away during rain.
- Wait to fertilize if the weather is very hot since plants are more easily burned then.
- If in doubt, fertilize less. Better to fertilize with a more dilute solution but more often.
How and when to fertilize will be in part 3 of this series on fertilizing. More specifics about fertilizing particular plants will be included in “Home Gardening Fertilizing Part 3: Vegetables, Citrus, Fruit Trees and Ornamentals”.
This blog post is brought to you by the Help Desk of the Master Gardeners of Alameda County. Subscribe to our blog!
Have a gardening question? We'll help. You can reach us by:
-
Emailing acmg@ucanr.edu. Please include a photo of the problem, if you can, plus your name, phone number, city and a description of the problem.
-
Using our online form.
-
By phone, during our office hours, 10 am to noon Wednesday and 11 am to 1 pm Thursday: 510-670-5645. At other times, please leave a message and we'll return your call during our office hours.
-
In person at our Hayward office, during our office hours, only by appointment.
Resources
- Questions and Answers about Soils and Fertilizer in the Garden from The University of California, The California Garden Web. The following link has lots of great information on soils and fertilizer in the home garden:
- The UC Master Gardeners of Marin County created a table that is a list of organic and inorganic fertilizer and soil amendments with N-P-K values where appropriate, accompanied by a description of the material.
- And another table from UCCE Lassen County - Notice the values are not always identical, but gives one a good idea of the approximate % of each of the three NPK.
- Organic amendments for landscape soils by J. Downer, B. Faber
- What Is pH and Why Do We Care?
- Common nutrient deficiency symptoms
- Information on fertilizers and how and when to fertilize in general from the UC Marin Master Gardeners "Fertilizing: Feeding the Soil, Not the Plant"
- The effects of nitrogen excess
- The EPA has information - "Sources and Solutions: Agriculture" about nutrient (fertilizer) pollution. While the focus is agricultural it contains good information and resources for the home gardener.
- How to Calculate How Much Fertilizer to Add: Prepackaged products will contain application instructions. If you don't know what to use, this fertilizer calculator from the University of Georgia can help you know how much fertilizer to apply when you have lab soil test results for N-P-K.
Calculating Fertilizer Application Rates without soil test values.
- Author: Judy Quan
In winter it's a normal process to see yellowing leaves and leaf drop. When we see this in other seasons, it indicates a problem. When we see the yellowing leaves on our citrus, we often jump to the conclusion there is an iron or a nitrogen deficiency, but there can be a variety of causes.
Before adding nutrients such as iron or nitrogen, consider things such as the time of year, watering practices, soil pH, general care practices, as well as the pattern of yellowing on the leaves.
Things to check first before adding nutrients:
√ Is it winter with cold soil temperatures?
√ Are rains or irrigation practices causing soil to be waterlogged?
√ Is soil pH alkaline, greater than 7.5?
√ What fertilizers have been applied?
√ What is the pattern of yellowing on the leaves, symptoms in older or younger leaves?
Certain conditions often make nutrients unavailable to plants, even though the nutrient may be present in the soil.
Alkaline soil pH. Soil pH is a measure of soil acidity/alkalinity, with 7.0 as the neutral point. Citrus, like other plants that are adapted to slightly acidic soil, are especially prone to iron deficiency when soil pH is above about 7.5 (alkaline). Alkaline soils hold onto iron, making it inaccessible to plants, even though typically iron is plentiful in most California soils. A pH of around 6.5 is ideal for citrus, but it can tolerate a range from 6.0 to 7.5. Adjusting soil pH needs to be done carefully and slowly to avoid unwanted effects in the garden.
Cold soil and soggy soil limit microbial activity important in getting nutrients to the plants. Microbes need porous soil and a certain temperature range to thrive, which is why chlorosis (yellowing leaves) is more common in winter. Porous soils have spaces in the soil that allow water and air to move easily in the soil. Compacted or clay soils are especially prone to a lack of porosity in cold, wet weather which may persist into spring.
Nutrient imbalances, especially an overabundance of zinc, copper, and manganese, can make iron less available. Causes vary, but imbalances can be due to over-application of certain fertilizers.
Identification: Iron deficiency symptoms: yellow leaves, green veins – primarily in young leaves. Nutritional deficiencies in citrus can be identified by the pattern of leaf yellowing and by noting whether it occurs on old or new foliage. The pattern of yellowing leaves between the small, darker green veins occurs primarily in young leaves. This happens as soils cool, reducing root activity. Other possible causes of that pattern of yellowing include zinc and manganese deficiencies. See the UC Integrated Pest Management website for pictures of various patterns of chlorosis.
What to do about iron deficiency?
Improve cultural practices and the soil environment.
- Make sure to irrigate with sufficient time between waterings to allow soil to dry but still provide enough water. Deep watering once a month is often sufficient, especially in summer.
- Make sure drainage allows roots to have air and water, avoiding waterlogged soil.
- Regularly add compost on top of roots, away from the crown of citrus. The addition of organic matter helps with iron deficiency as the organic matter decays and soil gradually becomes more acidic.
- If there has been a history of regular application of fertilizers, a soil test may be helpful to determine potential nutrient imbalances before applying more fertilizer.
- Iron, manganese and/or zinc deficiencies can be corrected with a foliar (leaf) application of a liquid micronutrient solution as the new growth emerges in the spring. You can also apply micronutrients, such as zinc sulfate or iron sulfate, to the soil. Microelements such as iron and zinc though, need an actively growing root system for uptake. Their soil application should be limited to the summertime.
Identification: Nitrogen (N) deficiency symptoms- leaves pale all over (light green or yellow), especially in older leaves. Nitrogen deficiency starts with older leaves near the bottom of the tree and foliage turns a uniform yellow. Slow growth and uniform yellowing of older leaves are usually the first symptoms of nitrogen deficiency. The causes include a true deficiency of nitrogen, adverse soil conditions, or unhealthy roots.
What to do about nitrogen deficiency in citrus?
Most citrus require regular fertilization with nitrogen. However, there are still conditions that would mimic nitrogen deficiency that would not be fixed by adding nitrogen.
- Wait until the soil is warmer, moist but not soggy, to apply nitrogen. Cold and soggy soil inhibits nitrogen uptake.
- Make sure to water with sufficient time between waterings to allow soil to drain well but still provide enough water to citrus. Deep watering once a month is often sufficient, especially in summer.
- Make sure drainage allows roots to have air and water, avoiding waterlogged soil, which often leads to rot and crown damage.
- Regularly add compost on top of roots, away from the crown of citrus. The addition of organic matter helps with iron deficiency as the organic matter decays and soil gradually becomes more acidic.
- Consider doing a soil test, either from a commercial laboratory or a home soil test kit. If there has been a history of regular application of fertilizers, a soil test may be helpful to determine potential nutrient imbalances and to know the current levels of nutrients such as N,P, K and pH.
- Remember it is possible to over-fertilize, potentially causing problems such as a delay in maturity and a reduction in fruit quality; so when in doubt, fertilize less.
When should citrus be fertilized?
Most mature citrus require regular fertilization with nitrogen.
- Begin nitrogen fertilization in February or March depending on the temperature, when soils are warmer and drier, just before pre-bloom.
- Fertilize only in the spring and summer months.
- Choose more frequent/small applications of nitrogen that allow more efficient nitrogen uptake, so less fertilizer is required.
- Or choose the more convenient schedule of three nitrogen fertilizations to be in February, early May and June – Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, Father's Day, with a last application perhaps in early fall.
- Stop applying nitrogen fertilizer if citrus leaf miner severely damages new foliage growth in late summer.
- Aim to go into winter with adequate nitrogen stored in the plant, so when spring comes, the nutrients are already there ready for the blooming period.
- Avoid late-season fertilization
- It may affect fruit quality, delay fruit coloring and make the rind rough.
- It stimulates new growth and makes trees more susceptible to frost injury. Subtropical plants, including citrus, develop some resistance to cold damage by going through quiescence, a resting time of no or slow growth when cooler temperatures arrive. Quiescence is induced several weeks after 40-50°F temperatures arrive. But that quiescence can be changed to active growing by pruning or nitrogen fertilization in early winter, increasing the possibility of cold damage.
- Avoid adding too much nitrogen, which can damage plants and cause other problems associated with nitrogen excess. Follow the directions on the package. If in doubt, fertilize less.
What fertilizer should be used?
- Nitrogen is the chief nutrient required by citrus and should be applied each year. Fertilizers commonly contain nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K), listed as NPK on the fertilizer label. Look for a fertilizer where the first number (nitrogen) is the highest of the three, e.g., 7-3-3; fertilizers formulated for citrus typically have higher nitrogen with lower levels of phosphorus and potassium. Avoid balanced fertilizers such those labeled 10-10-10. The relatively high concentrations of phosphorus and potassium are not needed since they are held in the soil much longer than nitrogen.
- Choose the type that best fits your needs. Nitrogen can be provided as organic matter, inorganic compounds, or commercial slow-release (e.g., suffer-or polymer-coated urea). Some fertilizers add nutrients only; other fertilizers are also amendments that indirectly affect plant growth by improving the physical properties of the soil. You can find more information about fertilizers and amendments from The San Luis Obispo Master Gardeners in their pdf handout.
When we see yellowing leaves in our citrus, we want a quick easy answer. But by taking a more comprehensive look at our citrus, the soil and the moisture levels in the soil, as well as the seasonal temperatures, we are more likely to correctly diagnose the problem and then effectively adjust factors that will result in healthier citrus trees. And fertilizing with the right amount of nutrients, mainly nitrogen, at the right time will promote the health and productivity of citrus while minimizing problems associated with overfertilization.
This blog post is brought to you by the Help Desk of the Master Gardeners of Alameda County. Subscribe to our blog!
Have a gardening question? We'll help. You can reach us by:
- Emailing acmg@ucanr.edu. Please include a photo of the problem, if you can, plus your name, phone number, city and a description of the problem.
-
Using our online form.
-
By phone, during our office hours, 10 am to noon Wednesday and 11 am to 1 pm Thursday: 510-670-5645. At other times, please leave a message and we'll return your call during our office hours.
- In person at our Hayward office, during our office hours, only by appointment.
Resources
- Adjusting Soil pH in California Gardens, a free downloadable PDF
- A Guide to Citrus Nutritional Deficiency and Toxicity Identification
- Citrus for the Home Gardener 2008 Vincent Lazaneo, Horticulture Advisor
- Diseases and Disorders of Leaves and Twigs
- Fertilizing Citrus in the Foothills by Cindy Fake
- Iron deficiency UC IPM
- Nitrogen deficiency UC IPM
- When to Fertilize Avocado and Citrus in California
- Author: Judy Quan
Help! My lemon tree has yellowing leaves and is dropping leaves… that is one of the most frequent requests we get at the Help Desk, especially in late winter and early spring.
When we see yellowing leaves on citrus, often we leap to the conclusion that it is nitrogen or iron deficiency. There are many causes of yellowing of leaves, not just nitrogen deficiency or iron deficiency. Some of the reasons for the yellowing of leaves will take care of themselves if we are patient and we wait for the soils to warm and dry as we emerge from winter temperatures and winter rains.
Yellowing leaves and leaf drop in citrus often occur in winter.
Winter leaf drop is part of the natural cycle of eliminating old leaves and their replacement with new leaves. Citrus sheds leaves year-round; the older leaves drop off, but in winter there are no new leaves to replace them.
Citrus often “rest” in winter, meaning no growth of new leaves, stems or roots. Citrus trees are evergreen tropical plants that are grown in subtropical regions; in winter, they go into a “quiescent” state, a kind of dormancy for subtropical trees. This is a kind of resting phase that is somewhat protective against frost. The winter temperatures are too low in many citrus-growing areas of California for vegetative growth, the growth of leaves, stems and roots.
The “winter yellows” are the yellowing of citrus leaves during the winter. The yellowing is most common on the later summer flush leaves, the leaves produced during the summer. Symptoms of winter yellows can include leaves that are pale all over with the older leaves often being affected first. The symptoms of winter yellows look like nitrogen deficiency, but the yellowing in winter likely is not due to the lack of nitrogen in the soil. Cool weather inhibits nutrient uptake, and then the leaves look as though there is a nutrient deficiency; however, if you tested the soil, the tests might show sufficient nutrients such as nitrogen or iron.
Root activity slows or stops when soil temperatures are low and soil is waterlogged. Leaf yellowing and drop in the winter is more likely due to excessive or too little water in the root zone or dry winds in combination with cool soils. Winds can cause more leaves to drop sooner, making it seem that there is more of a problem since the branches look more bare. Winter yellows can be more severe when we have winter rains that seem to come storm after storm, and the root zones become waterlogged. Soils that are too cold or wet do not allow the roots to absorb nutrients. Adding nutrients like nitrogen and iron during winter won't address the causes of winter yellowing of leaves.
Low temperatures hinder microbial activity that makes nitrogen more plant-accessible.
Cool soil temperatures inhibit microbial activity that is important to the processes of mineralization and nitrification, essential in the conversion of nitrogen to forms more accessible to plants.
- Mineralization is how microbes convert organic nitrogen to ammonium, an inorganic form of nitrogen which plants can absorb directly from the soil. Mineralization readily occurs in warm (68-95 degrees Fahrenheit), well-aerated and moist soils.
- Nitrification is how microbes convert ammonium to nitrate to get energy. Nitrate is the most plant-available form of nitrogen, but it is also the most susceptible to being lost to the plants due to leaching, which is when nutrients wash away in excess water. Nitrification is most rapid when soil temperature is between 67 to 86 degrees Fahrenheit but essentially stops when temperatures are below 41°F and above 122°F.
Want to measure your soil temperature? If you are curious whether the soil temperatures have reached the high sixties where the microbes are most efficient at making nitrogen accessible, you can use an instant-read probe, like the ones used for cooking or ones for soil. Insert the probe to the depth of the roots of the citrus. Test in the early morning for the lowest temperatures.
As temperatures warm up and as topsoil warms and drains, the trees generally gradually recover and the foliage re-greens. Look for the first flush of new growth in the spring. Healthy new leaves indicate a healthy tree, and your tree doesn't need additional nutrients right now.
This blog post is brought to you by the Help Desk of the Master Gardeners of Alameda County. Subscribe to our blog!
Have a gardening question? We'll help. You can reach us by:
- Emailing acmg@ucanr.edu. Please include a photo of the problem, if you can, plus your name, phone number, city and a description of the problem.
- Using our online form.
- By phone, during our office hours, 10 am to noon Wednesday and 11 am to 1 pm Thursday: 510-670-5645. At other times, please leave a message and we'll return your call during our office hours.
- In person at our Hayward office, during our office hours, only by appointment.
Resources
- Winter Yellows - Ben Faber
- Leaves on your Citrus Trees Turning Yellow this Winter? Don't Panic. by Ed Perry, emeritus Environmental
- Horticultural Advisor for University of California Cooperative Extension (UCCE) in Stanislaus County.
- Fertilizing Citrus in the Foothills
- Nitrogen Basics – The Nitrogen Cycle
- Nitrogen deficiency
- Nitrogen Management in Citrus and Avocado
- Author: Diane Allen
Spring is quickly approaching! To aspiring and experienced gardeners alike, that means it's time to begin the fun of choosing what to plant. This often includes which tomatoes to try, both old favorites and also some of the newer varieties.
There are so many tomatoes to choose from – how to even begin? Well, among other factors that can influence your choices, here are four key points to consider: Use, Growing Space, Climate and Disease Resistance. Even seasoned vegetable gardeners should find these four reminders helpful in choosing for tomato growing success!
Use
How will you be using your tomatoes? For fresh eating, as in salads or sandwiches? Making tomato sauce? Or perhaps you would like to sun-dry or can your tomatoes? There are types of tomatoes that are best suited for each of these different uses.
For fresh eating, vine-ripened large beefsteak and hybrid standard-size tomatoes are flavorful and good for slicing. Beefsteak tomatoes are especially large, and have smaller seed cavities than many other tomatoes, making them easier to slice. Somewhat smaller, round hybrid tomatoes like Early Girl are also delicious to eat fresh and generally ripen earlier than the larger beefsteaks. Standard-size tomato varieties also come in many different colors and color patterns!
Cherry tomatoes are small and often very sweet. Common varieties of sweet cherry tomatoes include Sun Gold, Sweet 100s and Sweet Million. They are fun to eat whole, even right off the vine. There are cherry tomato varieties in different colors that make a fun addition to salads and other fresh dishes. As a bonus, cherry tomatoes are also typically easy to grow! They freeze well and roasting them before freezing enhances their flavor.
Making tomato sauce? Roma, or paste tomatoes have a smaller, oval shape, thicker skins and lower water content than other types. For this reason, they are well suited for making tomato sauce. The thicker skins make them easier to peel and the lower water content results in less cooking time to reduce the liquid to a thicker consistency. Other tomato varieties with an elongated “plum” shape that are good for sauce and salsa are Amish Paste and San Marzano. All of these plum-shaped tomatoes are also good for drying due to their lower water content.
No matter how you like to use your tomatoes, you'll find many different varieties to try for each of these sizes and types. Be sure to try a new variety when you can; you may discover a new favorite!
Growing Space
You can grow tomatoes in any part of your garden or patio that has sun, but the amount of space you have available will help you in choosing which varieties to grow.
Tomato plant varieties have a wide spectrum of sizes. A large garden space or raised bed can accommodate any size of tomato plant; the larger varieties grow up to 5-6 feet tall and spread just as wide if not trimmed or supported upright. Just remember to allow at least 3-4 feet between plants of larger varieties to ensure air circulation and to reduce the spread of any diseases. Their size may limit how many plants you can or may want to dedicate to your tomato patch.
On the other end of the size spectrum, compact bush cherry tomatoes like Tiny Tim may only be 12 inches tall and 14 inches wide when grown in pots (a little larger when planted in the ground). These are perfect for patio and deck pots. You will still want to keep 18-24 inches between plants.
Determinate vs indeterminate
Tomatoes are described as determinate or indeterminate based on the plant's growth habit. This is another characteristic that affects the size of the mature plants and can help you choose the plant best suited for your growing space.
Determinate, or “bush,” tomato varieties have a somewhat bushy appearance, grow to a given size (between 3 to 5 feet), bear most of their fruit within 4 to 6 weeks, and then decline in vigor. Most early-ripening and canning tomato varieties are of the determinate type, as are some varieties that do well in containers. If you have limited space, determinate tomatoes have the advantage of being somewhat smaller than indeterminate plants.
Indeterminate varieties produce vines that continue to grow and set fruit all summer until they die from cold weather or disease. Many typical standard-sized and cherry tomatoes for the home garden are indeterminate varieties. Indeterminate plants can grow more than 5 feet tall and wide, and require much more space to grow. Left to grow without support, indeterminate plants also tend to sprawl on the ground, leaving the fruit susceptible to rot where it comes in contact with the soil. So support these plants with sturdy trellises, cages, or stakes. The branches of indeterminate plants can also be trimmed to help contain their spread, with acceptable sacrifice of fruit yield.
Bush varieties
Will you be growing your tomatoes in containers on your deck, balcony or patio? There are smaller, determinate bush varieties that do well in pots too! These include cherry tomato plants, such as the varieties Toy Boy and Small Fry. Better Bush VFN produces larger, good-sized fruit on compact plants growing 3-4 feet tall. It has more of an upright growing habit and does very well in pots.
Climate
Alameda County covers a large area, with vastly different local micro-climates. The cities in the western part of the county near the San Francisco Bay have cooler summer temperatures with some fog, while the eastern part of the county has dry, higher summer temperatures. Even within your yard you may find micro-climates. Your open unshaded areas may have a full day of direct sun and higher temperatures; more shaded areas of your garden will have fewer hours of sun and cooler temperatures. The average summer temperature of each of your growing areas is an important factor in the type of tomato that will be successful in that location.
Whatever your local climate, remember to also ask your neighbors what they are growing successfully. It's fun to exchange information and compare notes, and you may learn about a variety new to you!
Hot summer climates
Many of the larger beefsteak tomatoes, for example, require hot summer temperatures and have 75-100 days to maturity (i.e. the number of days it takes for the plant to become mature and to produce fruit). Even in the hot summers of the eastern part of the county, such as in Livermore, some beefsteak tomatoes will not ripen fully due to the time it takes to mature. To achieve more predictably good results in eastern Alameda County, you may want to plant beefsteak and hybrid tomatoes with 85 or fewer days to maturity.
Note that very hot weather can cause problems for tomatoes too. If temperatures are over 90 degrees for extended periods of time, tomatoes may drop their blossoms and the tomatoes can become sunburned while ripening. There are varieties that do well even during hot spells, such as Celebrity standard-sized and Sun Gold cherry tomatoes. You may want to try these if your garden experiences frequent hot temperatures.
Cool Summer Climates
Conversely, if you live near the bay or in the western part of the county, you may have average summer temperatures reaching only 67 to 75 degrees, and possibly some fog. But do not despair! Although tomatoes need sun to ripen, there are many varieties that do well in cooler temperatures. These are primarily those that reach maturity more quickly (50-70 days to maturity.) Using varieties with fewer days to maturity will give your harvest a longer time to ripen in your cooler climate.
Recommendations from the Master Gardeners Lake Merritt Trials Garden in Oakland over the past 10 years have included:
Cherry Tomatoes:
- Sungold: medium, orange cherry, great flavor, excellent yield, disease resistant; Sweet 100 or Sweet Million: small, red cherry, good flavor, good yield, disease resistant
Standard Tomatoes:
- Early Girl or Summer Girl: medium, red, great flavor, excellent yield, disease resistant;
Stupice: small, red, sweet flavor, excellent yield, disease resistant
Disease Resistance
Tomatoes are susceptible to several diseases that can reduce fruit yield or even kill your tomato plants. However, many hybrid varieties are resistant to these infections.
Some of the most common of these diseases are Fusarium wilt, Verticillium wilt and Tobacco Mosaic Virus. Hybrid varieties that are resistant to these diseases are fairly easily found. Look for the disease code letters on the tomato plant label next to the tomato variety name. Typically, the code is just the first letter of the disease, such as “F” for Fusarium, “V” for Verticillium wilt, “T” for Tobacco Mosaic Virus and “N” for nematodes. For example, “Super Sweet 100 Hybrid VF” indicates that the plant is resistant to both Verticillium and Fusarium wilt diseases. If you are growing your plants from seed, look on the seed packet for the code letters or a statement about resistance.
Note that disease resistance does not mean that the plant is completely immune to the disease noted. In parts of the garden where the disease has occurred in the past, even resistant varieties may experience some reduced growth and yield. For this reason, it's best to rotate the location of your tomato plants every year or two.
Try something fun and new
New varieties of tomatoes are being developed every year. They are fun to try, not only for flavor but also because they are in different colors, patterns and shapes. Below are a few examples.
Have fun in your garden and enjoy your tomatoes!
References and Further Reading
- Growing Tomatoes in the Home Garden, University of California ANR
- Best Types of Tomatoes for Canning from the University of Maine Cooperative Extension
- Tomato Transplants - pdf document
This blog post is brought to you by the Help Desk of the Master Gardeners of Alameda County. Subscribe to our blog!
Have a gardening question? We'll help.
You can reach us by:
- Emailing acmg@ucanr.edu. Please include a photo of the problem, if you can, plus your name, phone number, city and a description of the problem.
- Using our online form.
- By phone, during our office hours, 10 am to noon Wednesday and 11 am to 1 pm Thursday: 510-670-5645. At other times, please leave a message and we'll return your call during our office hours.
- In person at our Hayward office, during our office hours, only by appointment.
- Author: Jim Farr
Planting fruit trees is a rewarding and sustainable endeavor that brings the joy of fresh, homegrown fruit to your household. However, selecting the right fruit trees for your garden requires careful consideration of some key factors to ensure a bountiful harvest for decades. To help you embark on this fruitful journey, I have compiled a comprehensive checklist that covers essential factors to consider when picking out fruit trees from a nursery.
√ Choice of Type of Fruit
Choose fruit that you and your family enjoy eating. This may seem obvious but keep in mind that there will be times when you have an abundance of fruit. This will likely be far more fruit than your household can eat even if it's your favorite. My experience is that neighbors are very grateful to receive free fruit. Excess fruit can also be donated to food banks and churches. Look here to identify potential food donation localities near you.
√ Climate Compatibility
Your climate is a key consideration. Different fruit trees thrive in different climatic zones. Consult the USDA Hardiness Zone map to determine the climate zone of your region and choose fruit trees that are well suited to that zone. Review the USDA 2023 Hardiness Zone by zip code to check your neighborhood.
Checking the hardiness zone ensures that your tree can withstand the local temperature extremes. This is also important when considering chill hours which I will discuss below.
√ Soil
Most fruit trees thrive in deep, well-draining, granular soil with a slightly acidic to neutral pH (6.0-7.5). Amend the soil as necessary. Adding compost to the soil will help provide a slow-release fertilizer and help build the soil structure. However, do not replace all of the native soil, which may cause the tree to be root-bound. Use this blog as your guide to amending your soil to provide the optimal environment for your fruit tree.
It is important to recognize that some fruit trees have unique soil requirements. For example, blueberry bushes prefer more acidic soil in the pH range of 4.5-5.5. The normal neutral pH for soil is pH 7. Amendments can be added to the soil to make it acidic, such as sulfur. However, planting blueberries and other acid-loving fruit in containers allows for easier control of the soil pH.
√ Space Availability
Consider the available space in your garden. Fruit trees vary in size. Ensure you have enough room for the tree to grow to its mature size without overcrowding or competing with nearby plants. Fruit trees come in dwarf, semi-dwarf and standard (full) size. Look at the tag carefully for size information. Even a dwarf fruit tree can often still grow more than 8-10 feet, semi-dwarf trees up to 15+ feet tall and standard fruit trees up to 20-25+ feet. Dwarf or semi-dwarf varieties are suitable for smaller spaces, while standard varieties will be appropriate for larger areas.
√ Pollination Requirements
Some fruit trees require cross-pollination with another compatible tree to produce fruit. The tag will indicate whether the tree is “self-fruitful” or requires cross-pollination (sometimes referred to as “self-unfruitful”). For trees requiring cross-pollination check carefully which varieties are better for cross-pollinating than others. Sweet cherry fruit trees often require cross-pollination. The Bing cherry, for example, will require cross-pollination with another variety such as Stella or Sunburst varieties (which are self-fruitful).
Research the pollination requirements of the specific fruit tree you're interested in and ensure you have enough space for at least two trees if a pollinator is necessary. Alternatively, self-pollinating varieties are often available for those with limited space.
√ Chill Hours
Chill hours refer to the cumulative hours a tree requires at temperatures between 32°F and 45°F during the winter to break dormancy and produce a normal crop of fruit. With insufficient chill hours, trees will leaf out late in the season, blossoming can be prolonged, buds may deteriorate and/or drop, and few if any flowers are produced. It's a critical factor for fruit development for many fruit species including apples, cherries, nectarines, peaches, plums, apricots, and pears. Choose fruit trees that match the average chill hours of your region to ensure successful fruiting.
To find the average chill hours in your region see the link below that provides current and past chill hours data for various regions in the Bay Area. Some fruit tree varieties may require more than 1000+ chill hours while other fruit tree varieties may require much less, for example, 200 hours. Avoid fruit tree varieties that have chill hours on the borderline for the averages in your area. Average chill hours will vary from year to year and this will avoid years of marginal harvests.
Find the chill hours for your county.
√ Pest and Disease Resistance
Investigate the susceptibility of your chosen fruit tree(s) to common pests and diseases in your area. Choose varieties known for their resistance to common diseases to minimize the need for chemical interventions and ensure a healthier, more sustainable home orchard. The tags on fruit trees will indicate any disease resistance of a particular fruit tree variety. Some types of fruit trees have fewer natural diseases than others. For example, pomegranates and persimmons have fewer disease issues than other species of fruit such as cherries, plums, and peaches. For information on the common fruit tree diseases for a particular type of fruit, the University of California Integrated Pest Management website is very useful.
√ Fruit Ripening Time
To enjoy a continuous harvest throughout the season, choose varieties of fruit trees with different harvest times for your home orchard. This ensures a steady supply of fresh fruit rather than a glut all at once. Tags on fruit trees will indicate whether the particular variety of fruit tree is “early”, “mid-season” or “late”.
For example, if one wanted to extend the time when plums are ripe, planting the plum varieties Beauty, Santa Rosa, Burgundy, and Emerald Beauty will extend the harvest time from a typical 2 weeks for any one of these varieties to 3 months collectively. This can ensure a longer period of fruit harvest, as well as more flavor variety in the plums.
By timing the type and variety of fruit ripening dates, it is possible to have some fresh fruit available from May / June (apricots) all the way into October / November (apples).
√ Quality of Nursery Stock
Purchase fruit trees from reputable nurseries. Inspect the quality of the nursery stock, looking for well-developed root systems, disease-free foliage, and a straight, healthy trunk. Avoid trees with signs of stress, damage, canker sores, and pest infestations. Often people look for fruit trees already bearing fruit. Keep in mind that once planted, it is usually recommended to remove any existing fruit from the tree to minimize shock during planting.
√ Planting, Pruning, and Training Needs
Owning fruit trees is a decades-long commitment to care for the trees. Use the information provided by the UC California Backyard Orchard site on planting your fruit trees.
The amount of care a fruit tree requires after planting will vary with the fruit type. In general, fruit trees will require some annual pruning. Research the specific needs of your chosen trees to ensure proper care to maximize fruit production. If your tree size is beyond your reach, you will require professional help pruning your fruit tree. Review information on pruning fruit trees from UCANR to give you some idea of pruning considerations.
Conclusion
Selecting fruit trees for your garden involves carefully planning and considering various factors. By following this comprehensive checklist, you'll set the foundation for a thriving home orchard that will reward you with delicious, home grown fruit for years to come. Lastly, remember that the Alameda County Master Gardener Help Desk is only an email or call away if you have any questions about fruit trees or any other gardening issue.
References
Alameda County Master Gardeners Help Desk
This blog post is brought to you by the Help Desk of the UC Master Gardeners of Alameda County.
Have a gardening question? We'll help.
You can reach us by:
- Emailing acmg@ucanr.edu. Please include a photo of the problem, if you can, plus your name, phone number, city and a description of the problem.
- Using our online form.
- By phone, during our office hours, 10 am to noon Wednesday and 11 am to 1 pm Thursday: 510-670-5645. At other times, please leave a message and we'll return your call during our office hours.
- In person at our Hayward office, during our office hours, only by appointment.