Solution Center for Nutrient Management
Solution Center for Nutrient Management
Solution Center for Nutrient Management
University of California
Solution Center for Nutrient Management

Nutrient Management Research Database

General Information

Research Title

Detecting and Correcting Soil Calcium Limitations

Research Specifications

Crop: Lettuce, Melons
Soil Type:
County, State: (Fresno, Monterey, Sacramento, San Joaquin, Yolo), California
Year: 2007

Authors

Hartz, T.K., Smith, R., Chan, M.

Summary/Abstract from Original Source

A variety of experiments were conducted in 2005-06 to clarify issues regarding calcium availability in California soils, and the agronomic value of calcium fertigation on vegetable crops. A set of 23 representative agricultural soils was collected from fields in vegetable rotations in the Sacramento, Salinas, San Joaquin and Santa Maria Valleys. These soils were evaluated for calcium availability by two common laboratory techniques, ammonium acetate extraction and saturated paste extraction. To simulate the calcium concentration in actual soil solution, samples of all soils at field capacity moisture content were subjected to high-speed centrifugation, with the extracted soil solution analyzed for cation content. A greenhouse experiment evaluated lettuce Ca uptake from 15 of these soils; the study confirmed that soil solution Ca was the most accurate measure of Ca availability, followed by saturated paste extraction; exchangeable Ca was a poor measure of soil Ca availability. Saturated paste Ca was well correlated with soil solution Ca, and is the preferred method of analysis for routine soil testing (centrifugation is a research technique, not well suited to routine use by commercial laboratories). Soil calcium availability was generally high, ranging from 5-80 meq/liter (100-1,600 PPM) in soil solution; across soils, soluble Ca averaged 33 meq/liter (660 PPM), which represented 55% of cation milliequivalents. This level of Ca availability should provide adequate plant nutrition. The role of soil Ca availability in the development of tipburn in romaine lettuce was evaluated by surveying 15 commercial fields in the Salinas Valley. At harvest, plants were rated for the severity of tipburn on inner leaves (those most prone to the disorder); samples of inner leaves were analyzed for Ca concentration. Soil samples were analyzed for available Ca by saturated paste extraction. Three fields showed a significant level of tipburn. There was no correlation among tipburn severity, inner leaf Ca concentration and soil Ca availability, suggesting that factors other than Ca availability controlled tipburn development. Restricted crop transpiration appeared to be one of those factors; two of the three fields with tipburn encountered extremely low evapotranspiration conditions in the week before harvest due to fog off the ocean. A total of 5 field trials (3 on romaine lettuce, one on cantaloupe and one on honeydew) were conducted to determine the effects of fertigation of soluble calcium fertilizers [calcium nitrate (CN), calcium thiosulfate (CATS) and calcium chloride (CC)] through drip irrigation on crop yield, quality and Ca status. One to three fertigations were applied, at seasonal rates up to 30 lb Ca/acre. Calcium fertigation had no effect on lettuce yield or Ca concentration of inner leaves; tipburn was present in only one field, and Ca fertigation had no effect on tipburn severity. Similarly, Ca fertigation did not influence melon yield, fruit firmness (at harvest or after cold storage), or flesh Ca concentration. The effect of calcium enrichment of irrigation water on water movement through soils was investigated. In a laboratory assay the effect of adding 10 meq Ca/liter (200 PPM) to water on the rate of capillary water movement through three soils of varying Ca/Mg ratios was determined. In a field trial the effect of fertigation with CN, CATS or CC on root zone water distribution was investigated. In neither experiment did Ca enrichment of irrigation water modify water movement in soil.

Research Highlights

Design and Methods

  • While most common soil test methods show that California soils have adequate calcium, these tests are not always reliable metrics for plant available calcium.
  • This study evaluated several metrics for measuring soil calcium availability: ammonium acetate extraction, soil solution Ca, saturated paste extraction, and exchangeable Ca.
  • The role of Ca in romaine lettuce tipburn was also evaluated.
  • The effect of fertigated soluble calcium fertilizers on crop yield and Ca status was investigated.
  • The response of soil water movement to irrigation water calcium enrichment was also evaluated.

Results

  • Saturated paste extract was deemed the most effective method for common laboratory testing of Ca availability. The results of the saturated paste extract analysis were reflective of plant Ca levels.
  • There was no correlation among tipburn severity, inner leaf Ca concentration and soil Ca availability, suggesting that factors other than Ca availability controlled tipburn development.
  • Calcium fertigation had no effect on lettuce yield or Ca concentration of inner leaves; tipburn was present in only one field, and Ca fertigation had no effect on tipburn severity. Similarly, Ca fertigation did not influence melon yield, fruit firmness (at harvest or after cold storage), or flesh Ca concentration.
  • Ca application in irrigation had had little effect on water movement in soils.
  • These results suggest that the prevalence of tipburn, a sign of Ca deficiency, results from insufficient calcium movement within plants. The effects of weather are more important than calcium availability.

Additional Information

Tags (links to other subject matter in database)

Related Research in Fresno, Yolo, San Joaquin, Sacramento, Monterey Counties

Webmaster Email: calgutierrez@ucdavis.edu, kfarrar@ucanr.edu